Score: 10

"Finally a #1 rated flash worthy of being #1"

submission: Tarboy

date: September 28, 2009

It's about time those crap flashes like "There she is" were bumped off. This flash is actually creative and original, it doesn't play off any pre-established franchise or anything else, it's just damn good.

Good music, good animation, good story, good everything :D

Score: 10

"Genuinely funny."

submission: Life in Portal: Madness

date: September 28, 2009

There are a lot of people who upload flash with tons of newgrounds references and they become popular just because of the "inside joke" feel, however this flash was just plain funny - with or without newgrounds references.

Good job. :D

Score: 5

"Misleading frontpage icon."

submission: Cooking Sama

date: June 14, 2009

Based on the icon that newgrounds used on the frontpage - I clicked on this hoping to see hot lesbian, anime. Very disappointing.

I watched most of the flash (i think), but had to close it. Maybe it got better, but it's not really my thing. This seems like it caters to gay teenage boys who want to be Japanese. Am I right?

Is the author a hot chick? How else is this so popular? The art/style is awesome, but the content is lacking. I can see how certain "people" would love this, so I will give it a decent score for it being so professional looking.

Score: 10

"Very cool"

submission: Dark Town (Pizz. strings)

date: February 7, 2009

If I ever make another flash, I'd love to use this.

Score: 8

"Interesting effect"

submission: Mary Jane...Revisited

date: August 15, 2005

I like the little riff at the end with the guitar. Nice lyrics, but don't know how I feel about the pitching of the vocals and there's a bit of background fuzz on there that you coulda probably got rid of, but overall nice effort.